Law firm told to re-open books on client account

In a recent decision, the Ontario Court of Appeal upheld a client’s right to assess a lawyer’s account.

In McCarthy Tétrault LLP v. Guberman, McCarthys had represented immigration lawyer Joel Stephen Guberman in his divorce proceedings and later sued him for unpaid legal bills.

Guberman requested that the bills be assessed, claiming that his lawyer made several errors that caused him to suffer financially.

At issue was whether Guberman was entitled to have his lawyer’s accounts assessed. The Court of Appeal ruled in favour of Guberman.

“The right of a client to have a lawyer’s account assessed is an important one, not to be taken away except in compelling circumstances. As this court has stated, public confidence in the administration of justice requires the court to intervene where necessary to protect the client’s right to a fair procedure for the assessment of a solicitor’s bill,” the ruling stated.

James Morton, head of the litigation group at Steinberg Morton Hope & Israel LLP, says the key element in Guberman is that there is no time limit for assessment.

“The takeaway from this decision is that even after the one-month period when someone has a prima facie right to assess your account, the court will almost always permit the client to assess a lawyer’s account,” he says.

As a result, Morton advises lawyers to consent to clients’ requests for assessment of their accounts.

The decision delivers a bit of a blow to lawyers since clients can now assess accounts from years prior and then lawyers have to spend the time — unpaid — defending accounts that they may not have a strong recollection of, says Morton.

But the court seemed more concerned about the public’s confidence in the administration of justice than the hassle it may cause for lawyers.

“The courts have said here and in other cases . . . that the public needs to be confident that lawyers’ bills are fair and proper, and are subject to review by the courts,” says Morton.

Recent articles & video

Charter applies to self-governing First Nation’s laws, but s. 25 upholds Charter-breaching law: SCC

Parks Canada partnering with Indigenous groups to implement Indigenous systems of law, governance

Canada's Finest Legal Professionals: Celebrate Excellence at the Canadian Law Awards!

Are you keeping up with the dizzying pace of innovation?

Amanda Fowler on how she balances her sports law practice and legal role at Aviva Canada

Top 25 Most Influential Lawyers 2024 - nominations now open

Most Read Articles

Canada Revenue Agency announces penalty relief for bare trusts filing late returns

Ontario Court of Appeal upholds spousal support order in 'unusual' divorce case

Ontario Superior Court awards partner share in the estate despite the absence of marriage

Developing an AI oversight system is vital for organizations: Tara Raissi at Beneva