Johnson presses on with Brexit law-break plan after Lords defeat

Peers voted late Monday to remove the most controversial parts of the Internal Market Bill

Johnson presses on with Brexit law-break plan after Lords defeat

The UK’s House of Lords rejected government plans to break international law over Brexit, putting the onus back on Prime Minister Boris Johnson, who immediately vowed to push ahead with the legislation.

Peers voted late Monday to remove the most controversial parts of the Internal Market Bill, which gives ministers the power to unilaterally rewrite parts of the Withdrawal Agreement that Johnson signed with the European Union.

The legislation has prompted the EU to take legal action just as the two sides are locked in negotiations to strike a trade and security deal. But the prime minister has refused to back down over the plan, which the government has conceded will break international law in a “specific and limited” way.

“How can we reproach other countries – Russia, China, Iran – if their behaviour becomes reprehensible when we ourselves have such scant regard for the treaties we sign up to?” Michael Howard, who used to lead Johnson’s Conservative Party, asked the Lords. “What sort of a precedent is the government setting?”

Peers voted by 433 to 165 and then by 407 to 148 to remove clauses that would allow ministers to redraw parts of the Withdrawal Agreement.

Johnson’s office immediately issued a statement saying the clauses provide “a legal safety net to protect the integrity of the UK’s internal market” and they will be reinstated when the draft law returns to the House of Commons. The unelected upper house can only delay the legislation, not block it.

The bill would give ministers the power, if no trade accord is reached, to waive tariffs on goods traveling from the mainland to Northern Ireland, something that would upset the delicate compromise Britain and the EU reached during the negotiations to leave the bloc.

Johnson agreed then to levy tariffs on goods moving into Northern Ireland that were at risk of being moved south and into the EU as the price for avoiding customs checks on the border with the republic.

“We expect the House of Lords to recognise that we have an obligation to the people of Northern Ireland to make sure they continue to have unfettered access to the UK under all circumstances,” Johnson’s office said in the statement.

Cabinet Office Minister Nicholas True had earlier defended the bill and insisted the clauses were necessary and appropriate.

“The rule of law is a fundamental element in our constitution, but so is the principle of Parliamentary sovereignty,” True told the House of Lords. “It is permitted for any government in pursuit of the national interest to ask Parliament to legislate to authorise its acting in a manner that would be lawful in domestic law even if unlawful in international law.”


Copyright Bloomberg News

Free newsletter

The Canadian Legal Newswire is a FREE newsletter that keeps you up to date on news and analysis about the Canadian legal scene. A separate InHouse Edition is delivered on a regular basis, providing targeted news and information of interest to in-house counsel.

Please enter your email address below to subscribe.

Recent articles & video

Virtual arbitral hearings: Arbitrations are proceeding remotely with ‘enormous financial savings’

Canada’s top Wills, Trusts, & Estates boutiques for 2021 revealed

Changes to IP laws offers an easier path to industrial design protection, says Oyen Wiggs lawyer

University of Manitoba business law clinic aims to help entrepreneurs, innovators strapped for cash

Expediting the COVID response: how intellectual property regulators and tribunals have stepped up

More work needed to end violence against Indigenous women, LEAF says about Gladue retrial

Most Read Articles

Calgary lawyer Jeff Kahane could have bought carbon credits, but instead purchased land in B.C.

Manitoban on disability assistance wins right to appeal being forced to go on Old Age Pension at 65

Canadian Judicial Council to take no further action on matter of Quebec Superior Court chief justice

McLeish Orlando’s Lindsay Charles reflects on her journey to becoming a partner at the firm