Skip to content

Bill enabling deportation of foreign criminals too tough, lawyers say

|Written By Michael McKiernan

Immigration and criminal lawyers have teamed up to condemn a federal government bill that could see permanent residents deported after committing a crime that results in a jail sentence of six months.

Bill C-43, the faster removal of foreign criminals act, which passed second reading last week, removes the right to appeal removal orders to the Immigration Appeal Division of the Immigration Review Board when sentenced to six months or more in prison. The existing legislation allows appeals for those sentenced to less than two years in jail.

Mendel Green of immigration law firm Green and Spiegel LLP told a news conference this afternoon he was shocked by the “one-strike-and-you’re-out” policy for people who have been lawfully admitted to the country. He believes it could even violate the Charter’s ban on “cruel and unusual punishment.”

“Anyone who gets six months or more, they’re gone. . . . They’re banished almost like in Biblical times,” Green said.

“Canadians are a compassionate people,” added Robin Seligman, another lawyer at the conference. “Let someone take a look before you just bar them from the country.”

Toronto immigration lawyer Guidy Mamann said the title of the legislation was misleading.

“This legislation has nothing to do with the faster removal of foreign criminals,” Mamann said, adding that typical removal order cases involve permanent residents who were brought to Canada as children, and are entitled to citizenship, but have never taken it out for a variety of reasons.

He said the law “goes way too far” by failing to consider an affected permanent resident’s remorse, or the effect deportation would have on them or their family.

Another immigration lawyer, Barbara Jackman, said the bill is just one in a series of new laws that are fundamentally changing Canada’s approach to immigration, accusing the government of “piecemeal attacking and destroying the immigration system.”

“They don’t trust anybody to exercise discretion,” she said.

Andras Schreck, the vice president of the Criminal Lawyers’ Association, said his organization is concerned that the new six-month cutoff opens up a whole new category of crimes that could result in deportation. Whereas the old two-year mark meant only those sentenced to federal penitentiaries were denied an appeal to the immigration board, the new six-month cutoff captures some driving offences and even some summary offences.

“We’re not talking murderers, serial rapists or bank robbers,” Schreck said.

He said the criminal justice system could also expect to face greater costs and delays as permanent residents facing the disproportionate punishment of deportation fight charges rather than accepting responsibility for a crime that carries the potential of six months in jail.

“It removes the incentive to plead guilty,” Schreck said.

  • Ms

    Keesha Pryce
    My brother has been in this country since he was 7 years old and is now 30. He just spent the last 2 years in jail his sentence will be up on the 28th of this month and he is now facing deportation of course. How can he be considered a foreign criminal? How do you spend more of your life in one country and then if you don't turn out to be so good to be sent back. I understand why they think the law is needed but I don't believe one shoe fits all. He will be leaving behind a wife, daughter and step son.
  • Samantha
    I have plenty to say about the subject but i can assure you this is my last comment. I dont want people to be naive and take this bill at face value. Please consider this: If a permanent resident who came to canada as a child goes on to commit a crime here in canada who's burden is it?? Surely not the country they were born in!
    Does Jason Kenney not beleive that Canada should be responsible for the criminals it produces??
  • samantha
    Just another thought maybe Jason kenney cant handle the worklad so he's getting rid of it instead? I feel like this is a deflection... but from what i wonder???
  • samantha
    A fundamental principal of justice is that one cannot be punished for the same crime twice.My family is being personally affected by Jason Kenneys nazi like demeanor...its true this is not just impacting people with serious criminality its destroying lives over minor convictions! This isnt an issue of public safety this is a disillusioned man in the works of sabotaging what canada stands for. Boo Jason Kenny shame on you!! Your motives are unjust and unreasonable FRANKLY i think canada is better then this nonsense and should be aware of how the government is portraying this country furthermore stop referring to canadian residing citizens as FORIEGNERS its harsh and i cant imagine canadian citizens would tolerate this discrimination which by the way goes against charter rights! PLEASE somebody stop this man weve evolved past this intolerance why go backwards?
  • saber syed
    Conservatives are dictating on immigrants and posing before the community that There in no Canadian who has committed such crimes or canadian citizens are crime less.
    Why a criminal like Conrad Black was given permission before he was even released from Jail





  • clawbies 2015
    clawbies 2014
  • clawbies 2013
    clawbies 2012
  • clawbies 2011
    clawbies 2010