Login

Métis government launches legal challenge claiming Saskatchewan breached duty to consult

Action asks court to declare a policy invalid and province’s reliance on it dishonourable

Métis government launches legal challenge claiming Saskatchewan breached duty to consult

Métis Nation - Saskatchewan has filed an action before the Court of Queen’s Bench for Saskatchewan against the Government of Saskatchewan.

In the action, the MN-S questions the provincial government’s continued use and reliance on the 2010 First Nation and Metis Consultation Policy Framework.

The policy does not comply with the provincial government’s duties to consult, to uphold the honour of the Crown and to abide by the rights and protections owed by virtue of s. 35 of the Constitution Act, 1982, claimed the MN-S in a news release. These constitutional principles are meant to advance reconciliation, said the MN-S.

The action claims that Saskatchewan has failed to ensure that its notice and consultation policies comply with the MN-S Constitution, has failed to consult when issuing mineral interests within asserted Métis lands and has failed to take into account Métis land rights and commercial harvesting rights when reaching decisions potentially impacting Métis communities and their lands and resources.

The MN-S seeks a court order declaring that the policy is invalid and that the provincial government’s reliance on the policy to circumvent its duty to consult is dishonourable, as well as directing the identification and disclosure of all matters beginning in 2010 in which the province failed to consult because of its reliance on the policy. The MN-S is likewise asking for damages, costs and other relief that the court finds appropriate.

The MN-S expects that this action may also affect other Saskatchewan First Nations, which also experience challenges to consultation because of the policy.

The MN-S is a government that represents Métis citizens in Saskatchewan, as recognized by the “Metis Government Recognition and Self-Government Agreement” that it signed with the federal government in 2019. The MN-S also recently filed an action against NexGen Energy Ltd.

Related stories

Free newsletter

The Canadian Legal Newswire is a FREE newsletter that keeps you up to date on news and analysis about the Canadian legal scene. A separate InHouse Edition is delivered on a regular basis, providing targeted news and information of interest to in-house counsel.

Please enter your email address below to subscribe.

Recent articles & video

Appellant’s conduct signalled agreement to pre-incorporation contract, SCC finds

Former lawyers file complaint with Manitoba Human Right Commission over courthouse accessibility

N.B. law society urged to require members, articling students to take domestic violence course

Solving the ‘problem-solution’ problem for patent applicants: Choueifaty decision

Businesses may obtain cyber certification via CyberSecure Canada’s web portal

COVID-19 and the courts: Oct. 26 update

Most Read Articles

Cybersecurity due diligence becomes focus in M&A transactions

New Brunswick case a reminder careful wording is needed in termination letters, employment contracts

What corporate lawyers really do: Konata Lake on why he loves what he does at Torys

Disciplining a nurse who criticized long-term care via social media infringes free speech: case