A panel at the Canadian Legal Summit challenged lawyers to define their value before the algorithm does
AI as co-counsel is no longer a hypothetical. At the Canadian Legal Summit in Toronto in October 2026, a full-day event bringing together in-house counsel, law firm leaders and legal tech practitioners, the closing panel delivered a blunt message: the debate about whether AI belongs in legal practice is effectively over, and the more urgent question is what lawyers actually offer once the tool can already do its fair share of the work.
"It's not a question if AI is your co-counsel. It is your co-counsel," said Jonathan Leibtag, assistant general counsel of corporate, external and legal affairs at Microsoft. The session, titled "Clash of the Counsel: Is AI Your Next Legal Partner?," featured Leibtag alongside Phil Brown, senior counsel of practice management at the Law Society of Ontario (LSO); David Cowan FRSA, a law professor, author and advisor; and moderator Rick Liu, director of AI solution architecture, Canada, at Epiq.
Professional responsibility has not changed – the tool has
For Brown, despite the pace of technological change, a core principle remains: Nothing in the professional responsibility framework has shifted. "At the end of the day, the lawyer is still responsible for whatever output there is, no matter what tool they're using," he said. The competence and delegation rules that govern lawyers apply to AI output exactly as they apply to work produced by a junior – which means critical review is mandatory regardless of how polished the output appears.
The governance layer is where many firms using new technology remain exposed. "An NDA with your provider is not enough anymore," Brown said. A master services agreement and a data processing agreement are now baseline requirements, alongside clear answers on data sovereignty, retention periods, encryption, and breach notification obligations. The question of data sovereignty should concern any lawyer handling sensitive client files. "Is it safe to keep your client's information in the US right now? … I'm not sure what the answer to that question is," he said. Even enterprise systems don't eliminate the hallucination problem: "Just because it's an in-house enterprise system doesn't mean it's not going to make stuff up," he added.
The judgment gap no one has fully solved
Cowan began by reframing the conversation. "We should stop actually going on and on and on about artificial intelligence… I think we need to talk about augmented intelligence," he said. The goal is to create the most powerful combination of human thinking and machine capabilities, not to treat AI as a replacement for intelligence. The profession, he argued, has been distracted by the idea of lawyers being replaced: "It's tasks that have been replaced, not the job of lawyers," he said. "If you are happy to take the output of AI and pass it off as your work, then you've simply proven you're literally useless."
The practical challenge is a generation entering firms who may be less ready than they appear. Leibtag, drawing on experience teaching at a business school where every student could use AI freely, found that the quality of work still varied widely. "I wouldn't just ask to review the paper. I'd ask, can I see your prompts? Can I see your inputs?" he said. "Don't just review the output, review the input and be critical of their input because that really tells you how they're thinking about things."
Brown added the institutional dimension. "A number of law schools are now saying you can't use AI in law school at all. I think that is…the wrong way to go with that, because law firms have adopted AI wholesale and it's only moving faster."
What clients are now paying for
Leibtag said he occupies both sides of the table – as a client to outside counsel and a lawyer to business clients inside Microsoft. From both positions, he said the shift is clear. "I think our jobs have evolved where we're no longer in the business of options." Sophisticated clients can generate their own options through AI; what they want from their lawyers now is conviction, a recommended direction rather than a qualified range of possibilities. Yet the profession's training runs counter to this: "I think we typically are folks who caveat by our trade," Leibtag said – and that instinct is becoming a competitive liability.
Brown framed it in practical terms, drawing on his years in the criminal bar, describing how he set expectations directly at the retainer stage. "If you give me 30 pages of AI-generated legal knowledge or strategy, I'm going to charge you my fixed fee or hourly rate to review all of that information," he said. The value proposition he urged lawyers to sell is centred on what he called "that centaur chess concept."
"The machine plus the human is 99 percent of the time a better outcome," he said – and the lawyer's job is to be the human in that pairing who is worth having in the room.
Defining the value add before the client does
In his closing remarks, Leibtag – who has written for Canadian Lawyer on AI and legal judgment – delivered the session's most direct challenge. "We really need to define very specifically the value we add today," he said, adding that if that definition overlaps with what a tool already produces, the profession loses the argument. "The tools optimize and augment us and don't replace us. But it's up to us to develop that compelling narrative that that's in fact the case," he said.
For Cowan, the architecture of the conversation matters as much as the substance. Once lawyers start thinking in terms of augmented intelligence rather than artificial intelligence, "it gives you a kind of architecture to work with," he said. Brown closed on the foundational obligation: "You're ultimately responsible for anything that comes out under your name. And just be mindful of that and continue to operate at the same level of competence that you always have."
This session at the Canadian Legal Summit is also an episode of CL Talk, which can be found here:
The episode is also available on our CL Talk podcast homepage, which includes links to follow CL Talk on all major podcast platforms.
