Acid reflux spiked breath test results, judge rules

When Phillip Coffey was charged with impaired driving in August 2010, it left a bad taste in his mouth.

The Mono, Ont., man has acid reflux, a condition that sends a bitter fluid up his throat once in a while. He had such an episode just before his breath alcohol tests were taken on the evening a police officer pulled him over. In a recent decision, Ontario Court Justice Douglas Maund dropped charges against Coffey, ruling his acid reflux resulted in two false breath test results.

Even though Coffey only had three glasses of wine that evening, the regurgitated alcohol meant the breathalyzer picked up more alcohol than would normally be in his mouth, a toxicologist testified.

The expert’s opinion was that “the potential presence of mouth alcohol could have a dramatic effect and could produce abnormally high and false readings,” the judge said.

Another expert said this scenario would be very unlikely, but couldn’t rule it out.

In his verdict, Maund said scientific certainty is not needed to satisfy the requirement of reasonable doubt.

“What is necessary is to establish a realistic scientific possibility,” he said. “A reasonable doubt must be raised on the basis of credible evidence tending to show that the instrument was malfunctioning. I find that the evidence before me has established such a reasonable doubt as required by section 258(1)(c)(iv).”

Coffey had also told the court that he hadn’t taken his medication on the day of the incident.

“I find that I accept Mr. Coffey’s evidence that he was actually experiencing acid reflux symptoms during the breath tests. I found his evidence credible and he was unshaken in cross-examination,” the judge said.

“Having come to this conclusion, I find that it has been established that there was a real possibility that some alcohol may have been in Mr. Coffey’s oral cavity when the tests were taken. There was therefore a real potential for false readings from the instrument.”

Free newsletter

The Canadian Legal Newswire is a FREE weekly newsletter that keeps you up to date on news and analysis about the Canadian legal scene. A separate InHouse Edition is delivered every two weeks, providing targeted news and information of interest to in-house counsel.

Please complete the form below to receive the weekly Canadian Legal Newswire and/or the Canadian Inhouse Legal Newswire.

Recent articles & video

Daphne Dumont to receive CBA’s Cecilia I. Johnstone award

Quebec taking harsh line on cannabis edibles

Will the conversation catalyzed by the Law Society of Ontario mean the end of articling?

Copyright law: set for an overhaul?

Corporate Counsel Survey 2019 closes on Monday, Aug 26

When Legal Aid is a political prop, Access to justice suffers

Most Read Articles

Canadian Judicial Council seeks leave to SCC in Girouard case

The Ontario government is destroying university legal clinics

Quebec taking harsh line on cannabis edibles

Will the conversation catalyzed by the Law Society of Ontario mean the end of articling?