Both cases considered the mens rea element of establishing sexual assault
The Supreme Court of Canada dismissed appeals in two sexual assault cases Friday, confirming the conviction of an Ontario man and upholding an appellate court’s order to conduct a new jury trial for an Alberta man who was previously acquitted.
Both cases considered the mens rea element of proving sexual assault.
Here’s a breakdown of the two cases.
R. v. Degale
The case dates to an evening in December 2021, when a woman emerged from a van owned by her boyfriend’s brother barefoot, undressed from the waist down, and bleeding. She knocked on the door of an apartment down the hall from her boyfriend’s unit and told the people inside that someone was trying to kill her. Later that evening, she told her boyfriend’s sister-in-law that her boyfriend, Bevin Kerry Degale, had raped her.
When the police arrived, they found bloodstains and wet footprints in the common areas of the apartment building as well as a significant amount of blood in the van’s passenger seat. The police took her to the hospital, where she had to undergo surgery to treat multiple serious injuries. Degale was charged with aggravated sexual assault.
Neither Degale nor the complainant testified at trial. This left the Ontario Court of Justice, which oversaw the case, with limited evidence to work with: the testimony of Degale’s sister-in-law and neighbour, the testimony of the police officers, and physical, forensic, and medical evidence.
To establish aggravated sexual assault under the Criminal Code, the Crown must prove actus reus and mens rea – i.e., that the accused both committed the physical component of the crime, which involves the unwanted touching of a complainant, and had criminal intent. In Degale’s case, the trial judge found that the Crown had proven actus reus beyond a reasonable doubt, stating that it defied “common sense and human experience that [the complainant] consented to being injured in the manner she was during the course of sexual activity” with him.
However, the trial judge said the Crown failed to prove mens rea, since there was no evidence that the complainant told Degale she did not consent to sexual activity or that he was aware of her lack of consent. Degale was acquitted.
The Ontario Court of Appeal disagreed, finding that the evidence the trial judge relied on to establish actus reus also proved Degale’s mental state. The appellate court set aside Degale’s acquittal and convicted him of aggravated sexual assault.
Degale appealed the OCA’s decision, but the SCC dismissed his appeal and upheld his conviction in a 5-4 decision.
Writing for the majority, SCC Chief Justice Richard Wagner and Justice Mary Moreau said the trial judge should not have focused on the fact that there was no direct evidence available of the communication between Degale and the complainant.
The justices said the trial judge overlooked the evidence available to prove mens rea. This included circumstantial evidence that Degale knew of, wilfully ignored, or had been reckless about his ex-girlfriend’s lack of consent.
Wagner and Moreau said the trial judge also made “a clear legal error” by requiring the Crown to offer evidence that the complainant told Degale she did not consent.
“Canadian law has recognized for decades that there is no legal requirement to communicate non-consent to sexual contact,” the justices said.
In a concurring opinion, Justice Sheilah Martin agreed with the majority that convicting Degale was appropriate. However, Martin departed from the majority in her interpretation of s. 273.2(b) of the Criminal Code, which states that one of the defences available to an accused in sexual assault cases – that they genuinely misunderstood there was a lack of consent – is not available when the accused does not take reasonable steps to make sure the complainant was consenting.
Martin argued that Parliament’s introduction of this provision reflects “a basic premise: a person who wishes to engage in sexual activity bears a legal responsibility to turn their mind to whether the other person is communicating voluntary agreement.”
The justice said the introduction of s. 273.2(b) means there are two ways for the Crown to establish mens rea: one, by proving that the accused knew, wilfully ignored, or was reckless to the fact that the complainant had not consented; and two, by establishing that the accused intended the touching and failed to take reasonable steps to make sure consent had been communicated.
The majority had disagreed that s. 273.2(b) created this second pathway for proving fault.
Commenting on the case on Friday, Howard Krongold, a partner at criminal defence firm AGP LLP, told Canadian Lawyer that for years there has been a misunderstanding that an accused who is charged with sexual assault would be convicted if they could not raise the defence of honest but mistaken belief in communicated consent.
The understanding was that “there wasn’t a significant burden on the Crown or any real burden to prove intent,” Krongold says.
While this understanding has been challenged by appellate decisions over the years, the SCC’s ruling is significant for confirming that “there can be situations where an accused could be unable to raise the defence of honest but mistaken belief, but could nevertheless be acquitted based on the Crown's failure to prove mens rea,” the lawyer adds.
In an emailed statement, Julia Facca, the press secretary for Ontario Attorney General Doug Downey, said, “Our government has zero tolerance for any form of sexual violence. Victims and survivors expect their cases to be taken seriously and prosecuted vigorously.
“We respect the decisions of the Supreme Court of Canada and are carefully reviewing the decision in this matter.”
R. v. Bilinski
As with Degale, the SCC’s ruling on Bilinski grapples with questions around how to prove mens rea in sexual assault cases. It also addresses how jury instructions should be handled in such cases.
The events underlying the case took place in 2019, when the complainant invited her ex-boyfriend, Jordan Bilinski, to her home. Before he arrived, she texted him that he had to wear a condom if they had sex. However, when they had sex, Bilinski removed the condom and ejaculated in the complainant. The complainant later contacted the police.
Bilinski was charged with sexual assault and was tried by a jury in the Court of King’s Bench of Alberta. At trial, he did not defend himself by arguing that he honestly but mistakenly believed that the complainant had consented.
The judge gave the jury instructions on consent, but failed to clearly explain how the complainant’s lack of consent relates to actus reus, while Bilinski’s state of mind about her non-consent relates to mens rea. The jury acquitted the accused.
In a split decision, the Alberta Court of Appeal ordered a new trial. The appellate court majority found that the trial judge failed to explain to the jury that consent must be communicated by words or conduct. The majority also said the trial judge should have instructed the jury that if it concluded that the complainant had not consented, it should have “little difficulty” finding that Bilinski knew about, wilfully ignored, or was reckless about her lack of consent.
In a 7-2 decision, the SCC dismissed Bilinski’s appeal and agreed that he should be retried.
Writing for the majority, Justice Martin said that the question of how the Crown must prove mens rea had been addressed in Degale. Her ruling focused instead on whether the trial judge should have given the jury instructions that included the “little difficulty” language.
Martin said the Crown must prove that Bilinski had criminal intent beyond a reasonable doubt to establish that he is guilty of sexual assault. Trial judges do not have to tell juries that if they find a complainant did not consent, they should have “little difficulty” concluding that the accused knew about, wilfully ignored, or was reckless about the lack of consent, Martin said. She said such an instruction could actually interfere with the jury’s task of independently assessing whether the Crown has established the accused’s state of mind.
The trial judge therefore did not err by failing to provide the instruction. However, Martin said trial judges can instruct in the right circumstances.
While the justice concluded that this component of the trial was sound, she said the trial judge made another error by failing to clearly explain that consent must be communicated through words or conduct, and that a person cannot simply assume that someone has consented to sexual activity.
Based on these inadequate instructions, the jury could have acquitted Bilinski on the basis that he believed or assumed the complainant had consented, Martin said, adding this risk justifies a new trial.
Justices Suzanne Côté and Malcolm Rowe dissented, stating there was no legal basis on which to interfere with Bilinski’s acquittal.
In a statement, Yoav Niv, the sole practitioner who represented Bilinski, said he was encouraged by the majority’s findings on the “little difficulty” instruction and what it “means for the proper role of a jury in sexual assault trials.”
However, Niv said he was concerned about a retrial.
“The possibility of a conviction on retrial remains an abstraction, particularly given that the alleged offence occurred more than seven years ago,” Niv said. “At some point, the finality of a jury's acquittal must carry real weight. We hope this will take place following a retrial.”
A spokesperson for the Alberta Attorney General did not respond to a request for comment.