Terminated employee says ex-representative failed to timely re-engage grievance process
Upon determining that the Canadian Human Rights Commission (CHRC) had unreasonably applied s. 42(2) of the Canadian Human Rights Act, 1985 (CHRA), the Federal Court set aside the CHRC decision refusing to hear a terminated employee’s discrimination complaint.
Correctional Service Canada (CSC) employed the applicant in Foster v. Canada (Attorney General), 2026 FC 1401, for around 27 years. In 2015, personal difficulties began to affect his work performance.
CSC launched an internal investigation into the applicant’s performance in May 2016, as well as unsuccessfully attempted a disciplinary interview in the months that followed. On Nov. 21, 2017, CSC terminated his employment.
Grievance process
Before the Federal Public Sector Labour Relations and Employment Board, the applicant’s union commenced two grievances on his behalf on Dec. 14, 2017, under the Federal Public Sector Labour Relations Act, 2003.
Human rights complaint
Through a disability and racial discrimination complaint brought before the CHRC in 2018, the applicant sought to preserve the applicable one-year limitation period.
In a letter sent to the applicant on Nov. 22, 2018, the CHRC informed him that it might decline to deal with his complaint under s. 41(1)(a) of the CHRA due to the non-exhaustion of the grievance process.
Paralegal’s advice
In March 2022, amid his frustrations with the lengthy grievance process, the applicant hired a licensed paralegal, who suggested he withdraw from the grievance process and concentrate instead on the CHRC complaint.
Upon the applicant’s request, his union withdrew the grievances, so the scheduled hearings were vacated.
Canadian Human Rights Commission’s decision
The paralegal then tried to reactivate the 2018 human rights complaint.
On Mar. 19, 2025, the CHRC declined to deal with the human rights complaint under s. 41(1)(a) of the CHRA, given the discontinuance of the grievance process and the non-exhaustion of the adjudication process.
Judicial review application
In a judicial review application, the applicant sought to set aside the CHRC decision. He asserted that the paralegal was incompetent because she failed to:
- inform him that a mandamus order could have addressed the delay in the grievance process
- tell him about the risk of the CHRC’s refusal to hear his complaint based on the non-exhaustion of the grievance process
- re-engage the grievance process upon the scheduling of a hearing date
Federal Court quashes the CHRC decision
Upon considering the CHRC decision unreasonable, the Federal Court granted the judicial review application and returned the matter to the CHRC for reconsideration. The court awarded the applicant $2500, the agreed amount of costs.
According to the court, the CHRC unreasonably applied the pertinent statutory constraint, s. 42(2) of the CHRA, which required the CHRC to find that the failure to exhaust the grievance process was attributable to the applicant, rather than to someone else.
Findings about the applicant’s representatives
Based on a report of the CHRC’s human rights officer, the Federal Court noted that the officer knew that both the union and the paralegal represented the applicant.
“Given the recognition that the Applicant had two representatives, it was not reasonable for the Commission to only satisfy itself that the Applicant’s failure to exhaust the grievance process was not attributable to his union, without considering whether it was attributable to his paralegal,” Justice Michael Battista wrote for the court.
The court explained the inclusion of “another” in s. 42(2) could broadly cover more than the applicant’s bargaining agent.
Given the misapplication of the relevant threshold statutory consideration, the court found it unnecessary to address the applicant’s ineffective counsel claims.
Other federal cases on labour and employment law
On Aug. 7, the Federal Court of Appeal confirmed the absence of an active collective agreement between the British Columbia Maritime Employers Association (BCMEA) and the International Longshore & Warehouse Union-Canada (ILWU) during the ILWU’s illegal strike, given the combined effect of the Labour Code’s applicable provisions.
On Mar. 3, the Federal Court of Appeal affirmed the rejection of employment insurance benefits requested by an employee who failed to timely advance his argument that his employer’s vaccination policy infringed his Charter rights to religious freedom and bodily autonomy.
Enjoy this story? Read the latest labour and employment law news on the main page!