Business federation research shows eight WCBs in Canada are holding excess funds of $4.5B
According to its recent research snapshot, the Canadian Federation of Independent Business (CFIB) reported that 84 percent of small businesses surveyed would support legislation obligating workers’ compensation boards (WCBs) to give surplus funds back to employers.
Per CFIB’s new research, the WCBs in British Columbia, Manitoba, New Brunswick, Newfoundland and Labrador, Nova Scotia, Prince Edward Island, Quebec, and Yukon were hoarding $4.5 billion over their funding targets.
CFIB’s recommendations
In its media release, CFIB urged Canada’s WCBs and governments to:
- Return excess WCB funds to employers or decrease employer premiums if the funding ratio is over the board’s funding target, ideally via direct rebates to eligible employers
- Pass legislation requiring the return of surplus funds to such employers
- Introduce mandatory distribution policies with specified thresholds and payment schedules for the regular return of excess funds
- Set dates for publicly announcing WCB funding levels
- Report publicly on the number and cost of psychological injury claims, as well as assess the premium impact of any coverage expansion before its implementation
CFIB said these recommendations would help ensure fairness, certainty, transparency, and accessibility.
Per CFIB’s estimates, giving the surplus funds back to employers could result in an average rebate of around $2,600, and up to approximately $8,600 in Yukon.
Ontario’s treatment of WCB funds
According to CFIB, while most WCBs have a policy to give back excess funds, Ontario is the only province with legislation requiring the return of surpluses to premium-paying employers, with:
- mandatory rebates when the Workplace Safety and Insurance Board (WSIB) funding level is at least 125 percent
- rebates at the discretion of the WSIB when the funding level is at least 115 percent
While remaining within its target funding range, Ontario gave $4 billion back to employers in two rounds last year.
Psychological injury claims
Based on its research, CFIB acknowledged the rise in Canada of psychological injury claims, including post-traumatic stress and harm due to workplace harassment.
CFIB shared that:
- In British Columbia, accepted psychological injury claims increased by 51 percent between 2021 and 2025
- In New Brunswick, traumatic psychological injury claims decreased by 26 percent last year, which WorkSafeNB attributed to prevention efforts and mental health support
More news on workers’ compensation
In a workers’ compensation proceeding, the New Brunswick Court of Appeal issued a Mar. 31 ruling denying the appellant’s motion asking the appeal court to identify her solely by her initials in the style of cause, endorsements, appeal reasons, and other publicly accessible records.
In July 2025, the British Columbia Supreme Court upheld the Workers’ Compensation Appeal Tribunal’s certification of an action upon finding that the parties were an employer and three of its employees, one of whom suffered injuries arising from her employment.
Enjoy this story? Read the latest labour and employment law news on the main page!