BCSC rules officer error alone is not enough in a prison negligence claim
Nolan Swallow was stabbed moments before his release on day parole by Dennis Fletcher, a fellow inmate at Matsqui Institution. The correctional officer who freed Fletcher had broken institutional protocol. Yet the British Columbia Supreme Court still dismissed the prison negligence claim.
Prison negligence under Canadian law
Under the Corrections and Conditional Release Act (CCRA) of British Columbia, the Correctional Service of Canada (CSC) must provide safe and humane custody of federal offenders. The Attorney General of Canada is vicariously liable for the torts of CSC employees under the Crown Liability and Proceedings Act (CLPA).
A successful prison negligence claim must prove four things:
- a duty of care was owed
- that duty was breached
- the plaintiff suffered damage
- the damage was caused by the breach
Duty of care is usually conceded in these cases. Courts recognise that prisons are dangerous places and inmate behaviour is unpredictable. As such, the standard is not perfection.
How courts assess foreseeability in inmate assault cases
In Swallow v. Canada (Attorney General), 2026 BCSC 2214, it was explained that courts examine foreseeability closely in inmate assault cases. It cited several key decisions that have shaped a consistent framework:
Where courts found liability
- a predictable gap in supervision, such as a recurring period when inmates are left unmonitored at the same time each day, can make violence foreseeable
- a prior altercation or known conflict between inmates, combined with inadequate surveillance, can establish a pre-indicator of violence sufficient to ground liability
Where courts found no liability
Without known incompatibles or pre-indicators of violence, courts have held that an assault is foreseeable only if the institution had actual or constructive knowledge of a specific threat.
Why an officer’s breach alone did not create Crown liability
In this case, the court ruled that the CSC was not liable because the attack on Swallow was not reasonably foreseeable. It found that the officer breached the standard of care by releasing Fletcher without verifying the counselling appointment claim. The court also found this was a factual cause of the attack. Despite both findings, the prison negligence claim failed.
Swallow argued harm was foreseeable on four grounds:
- both he and Fletcher had violent criminal histories
- a prior attack in June 2016 suggested someone wanted him harmed
- withdrawing from criminal activity may have made him a target
- Fletcher was released minutes after Swallow was paged to leave, within earshot of the whole unit
The court rejected every argument. The two men had no violence-related incidents with each other at Matsqui. The June attacker had been transferred to another facility with no known link to Fletcher. No evidence showed officers knew Swallow was perceived as an informant. The timing, the court held, was only meaningful in hindsight.
A second claim also failed. Swallow argued officers should have stopped Fletcher from loitering in a corridor for about 90 seconds before the attack. No evidence showed any officer saw him there, and no duty to act on loitering in that setting was established.
Bookmark Canadian Lawyer’s Personal Injury page for more news, articles, and updates for Canadian legal professionals.