Limitation period didn’t begin running as he continued possessing investment property, judges find
In proceedings involving two tenants in common, each with a 50 percent interest in an investment property, the Ontario Court of Appeal did not consider a beneficial ownership claim statute-barred, given that the 10-year limitation period had not started running.
In Harris v. Melo, 2026 ONCA 798, the parties were in a relationship at the time. The appellant planned to purchase an investment property with a third party, who ultimately could not participate in the purchase.
Thus, the appellant asked the respondent to replace the original co-purchaser. The respondent agreed to include her name in the title and to co-sign the corresponding mortgage documents.
Property purchase
In 1989, the parties purchased the property as registered tenants in common, each with a 50 percent interest. The appellant entirely funded the down payment.
In 1990, the parties broke up. The whole time the parties remained on title, the appellant was the only one who managed the property and received rent from tenants.
Ontario Superior Court proceedings
In his application, the appellant sought a declaration that:
- He was the 100 percent beneficial owner of the property
- The respondent held her interest in trust for him
On July 23, 2025, Justice Mario D. Faieta of the Ontario Superior Court of Justice denied the appellant’s application. The application judge determined that:
- The 10-year limitation period in s. 4 of Ontario’s Real Property Limitations Act, 1990 (RPLA), barred the application
- The appellant would have been entitled to the requested declaration if the claim had not been statute-barred
- The respondent told the appellant about her intention to dispose of her property interest in 1995, if not earlier, which put the appellant on notice of her position that she held the legal and beneficial title to her 50 percent interest
The application judge granted the respondent’s application for the partition and sale of the property.
Ontario Court of Appeal allows appeal
On appeal, the appellant asserted that s. 5(1) of the RPLA governed his request for relief, thus delaying the starting of the limitation clock under s. 4.
While not opposing the appellant’s attempt to raise this new issue on appeal, the respondent countered that s. 5(1) was inapplicable.
The Ontario Court of Appeal set aside the decision. The appeal court declared the appellant as the sole beneficial owner of the property, including the respondent’s interest. The appeal court ordered the respondent to pay the appellant $28,445.85 as costs of the proceeding.
Applicability of s. 5(1)
The Ontario Court of Appeal ruled that s. 5(1) of the RPLA governed. Given that the appellant had been in continuous receipt of rent since the property purchase, the appeal court noted that it had all the facts relevant and necessary to determine the legal issue.
Considering the facts, the appeal court explained that the limitation period did not begin running as the appellant had maintained possession of the property and had never been dispossessed, in accordance with Waterstone Properties Corporation v. Caledon (Town), 2017 ONCA 623.
Thus, by operation of s. 5(1), the appeal court concluded that the appellant’s application was not statute-barred.
The appeal court rejected the respondent’s argument that s. 5(1) would apply when the claimant lacked legal title to the property, but obtained his entire interest through adverse possession.
Purchase money resulting trust
Lastly, the Ontario Court of Appeal confirmed that the respondent’s interest was subject to a purchase money resulting trust in favour of the appellant.
The appeal court upheld the application judge’s finding that the respondent had failed to rebut the presumption of a purchase money resulting trust in the appellant’s favour.
Ontario Court of Appeal’s other real estate cases
In a proceeding arising from an agreement of purchase and sale of real property, the Court of Appeal for Ontario made an Aug. 19 decision denying a motion to review a decision granting a motion to enforce an order to transfer title.
In a case involving a failed real estate transaction, the appeal court issued a July 7 order for a new trial before another judge to determine whether a real estate agent had breached the standard of care by contributing to his clients’ misunderstanding of a purchase agreement.
Enjoy this story? Read the latest real estate news on the main page!