Issue was whether large gratuitous transfers were gifts or investments subject to resulting trust
A recent Ontario Court of Appeal decision is an important reminder that the recipient of a large gratuitous transfer should establish that the deceased intended it as a gift, says Daniel Walker, managing partner of Bobila Walker Law.
Walker emphasizes that the burden of proof does not lie with the estate in that situation.
“The Court of Appeal made clear that missing loan paperwork does not establish a gift, and that a close personal relationship, however genuine, does not replace the independent corroboration the Evidence Act requires when the other party has died,” Walker tells Canadian Lawyer.
Facts of the case
Waters Estate v. Henry, 2026 ONCA 704, involved the estate of a wealthy businessman and philanthropist.
On nearly 400 occasions over a decade, the deceased (“William”) transferred money to a woman (“Gillian”) hired to care for his housebound wife (“Phyllis”). Most of these funds were William’s, but some were his wife’s.
Gillian used the money on properties, cars, jewellery, trips, and clothes, among other items. William eventually passed away.
Estate’s suit
After learning more about the details of William’s transfers to Gillian, those administering his estate filed a lawsuit seeking the return of the funds and the properties bought with that money.
The estate claimed that:
- William was the beneficial owner of the properties
- Most of the transfers were not gifts, but were instead investments subject to a resulting trust
Trial judgment
On July 31, 2024, Justice John Callaghan of the Ontario Superior Court of Justice ruled primarily in Gillian’s favour.
Except for one property and two fund sources, the trial judge ruled that Gillian rebutted the presumption of resulting trust, such that most of the transfers and purchases were gifts.
Regarding the exceptions, the judge determined that:
- William maintained an 80 percent ownership interest in a horse-riding stable business that Gillian purchased primarily with his funds
- Given that there was unjust enrichment, Gillian should repay $2.85 million belonging to Phyllis
- Gillian should also repay $970,000, representing outstanding loans to the estate, plus sums owed under a Feb. 24, 2014, security agreement
Appeal and cross-appeal
On appeal, the estate sought to set aside the trial judgment. The estate asked the appeal court to conclude that the transfers, apart from some credit card payments, were subject to a resulting trust.
The estate alleged that the trial judge erred in:
- determining that Gillian rebutted the presumption of resulting trust
- finding William’s handwritten notes inadmissible as hearsay evidence
- reversing the burden of proof, thus requiring the estate to establish that the transfers were subject to a resulting trust
- misapplying the corroboration requirement in s. 13 of Ontario’s Evidence Act, 1990
Meanwhile, on cross-appeal, Gillian asserted that the judge erred in:
- finding that William retained a beneficial interest in the stable business
- awarding money to Phyllis, who was not a party to the proceedings
Ontario Court of Appeal grants the estate’s appeal
Upon allowing the estate’s appeal, the Ontario Court of Appeal ordered a new trial on the issues involved. The appeal court then wholly dismissed Gillian’s cross-appeal.
The appeal court set aside and ordered a new trial for the trial judge’s findings:
- regarding whether the transfers, save for any sums paid toward a credit card, were gifts
- that some of the estate’s submissions were statute-barred
- that dismissing the estate’s fiduciary duty breach claim would be appropriate
- that all William’s notes, excluding a September note, were inadmissible
Walker highlights the appeal court ruling’s practical guidance on evidence.
“Courts should distinguish between types of transfers instead of treating a decade of payments as one intention,” Walker says. “A deceased person’s own records, even private notes, may be admissible to show how they saw the transfers.”
Affirming some of the trial judge’s conclusions, the appeal court held that:
- William maintained an 80 percent beneficial interest in the stable business
- Gillian should pay the outstanding loans, plus interest, as well as the amounts owed under the security agreement
- Gillian should pay the estate $1,938,000, representing the amount to which Phyllis was entitled
Costs
The Ontario Court of Appeal upheld the trial judge’s finding that Gillian should pay the estate $700,000 in costs.
Lastly, the appeal court ordered Gillian to pay the estate the appeal costs and cross-appeal costs amounting to $50,000, all inclusive.
Insights for estate litigators
“For estate litigators, the decision strengthens the hand of estate trustees who find large lifetime transfers to caregivers or other people close to the deceased,” Walker says. “For advisors, it reinforces the need to record what the client intended when the transfer is made. Where hindsight is the only evidence, the presumption of resulting trust will often decide the case.”
Bobila Walker Law is an estate and trust litigation firm in Toronto.
Ontario Court of Appeal’s other estate cases
For dependant support claims under Ontario’s Succession Law Reform Act, 1990 (SLRA), the Court of Appeal for Ontario issued a Nov. 6 ruling that a judge should have considered the claimants’ presence in the province as a presumptive connecting factor.
Last May 21, a three-justice panel of the appeal court declined to reconstitute itself as the Divisional Court to address an application for leave to appeal from a Superior Court order interpreting s. 21.1 of the SLRA.
Enjoy this story? Read the latest trusts and estates law news on the main page!