For years, legal orgs have pushed back against policy requiring intervenors to make remote appearances
The Supreme Court of Canada is launching a pilot project this spring that will require intervenors to jump through additional hoops to present oral arguments, but those granted permission will be allotted more time and allowed to present arguments in person in Ottawa.
Announced Thursday, the project has been applauded by some legal organizations that frequently intervene in cases before the high court. Many of these groups have pushed for a return to in-person oral arguments by intervenors for years, after remote appearances became the norm during the COVID-19 pandemic.
The pilot project is set to take effect on April 12, 2027 and introduces several changes to how intervenors appear before the SCC. Under the high court’s current rules, parties that have been granted intervenor status and ask for permission to present oral arguments are automatically granted five minutes for those arguments. When intervenors are attorneys general, they are granted 10 minutes.
The pilot project will still require intervenors to request the opportunity to make oral arguments explicitly. However, intervenors will need to explain how orally presenting their submissions will be useful to the SCC. Those granted permission will be given between five and 10 minutes to make their case. Critically, they will be able to choose whether to present their arguments remotely or in person before the high court’s justices in Ottawa.
The pilot project also introduces a new rule that SCC rulings will list only up to four of the lawyers representing each intervenor.
It will not change the criteria for whether an individual or group will be granted intervenor status in the first place.
However, some lawyers say a lack of specific details about the pilot project raises questions about how the changes will work in practice.
“We’re… wary of some elements that could potentially impact access to justice if they are implemented restrictively,” Harini Sivalingam, the director of the equality program at the Canadian Civil Liberties Association, says of the pilot project.
Sivalingam pointed to the requirement that intervenors seek permission from the SCC to present oral arguments. While this requirement exists under the current regime, intervenors are typically granted permission upon request. The new rules appear to leave open the possibility that the high court will exercise more discretion and reject requests.
“What we are concerned about is that if it’s overly restricted, it could potentially cut out participation of really important public interest organizations and voices and community representatives because it is an additional hurdle,” Sivalingam says. She adds that the pilot project seems to suggest the SCC is “moving towards restricting the number of intervenors that are appearing before the court.”
Brandon Kain, a partner at McCarthy Tétrault who has represented appellants, respondents, and intervenors before the SCC, argues that “the devil will be in the details here… in how the court proceeds in granting leave to parties to make oral argument.
“Are they going to adopt an approach where oral argument is generally not granted subject to specific circumstances, or are they going to be granting oral argument as a matter of course?” he asks.
Asked why the SCC is introducing the pilot project, SCC spokesperson Vanessa Racine said Thursday that the high court is seeking to give intervenors more flexibility while ensuring that access to justice remains at the forefront of decisions regarding participation in hearings.
“The court recognizes the importance of striking the right balance between accessibility, effectiveness, and fairness in its procedures,” Racine said.
She emphasized that submissions receive equal consideration whether presented in writing, in person, or virtually.
Fewer voices in the courtroom
Like Sivalingam, Thomas Slade, a partner at Supreme Advocacy who frequently appears before the SCC, understands the pilot project as an effort to reduce the number of oral arguments that the high court hears. However, the approach makes sense to him.
“The most obvious impact will be fewer voices in the courtroom as the court is more selective about who gets to make oral submissions, but I see it as the court going for a quality over quantity approach,” Slade says. “If you have 20 intervenors each speaking for five minutes, some of the advocacy likely gets lost in the shuffle.
“Bringing that down to a select few intervenors speaking for 10 minutes each will likely be more effective.”
Stephanie DiGiuseppe, treasurer and litigation committee co-chair at the Criminal Lawyers Association, agrees that the few extra minutes make a difference. She pointed to a recent appeal in which the CLA and another organization, each intervening separately in the case, hired the same lawyer so that he would cumulatively have 10 minutes to deliver his oral arguments instead of 5.
That approach “reflected this thought that this was a very important appeal with a very serious issue, and that… it would simply be beneficial to have a lengthier time period for intervention,” DiGiuseppe says.
However, Angela Marinos, chief general counsel at the Raoul Wallenberg Centre for Human Rights, raised concerns about what criteria the SCC will use to determine which intervenors can make oral arguments. The RWCHR frequently intervenes in cases before the high court.
Under the SCC’s current rules, individuals and groups who are granted permission to intervene in a case have presumably proven that their written and oral submissions are useful and beneficial. “Is there an extra hurdle to jump across now for oral submissions?” Marinos asks.
The lawyer also questioned the SCC’s assertion that the pilot project will give authorized intervenors a period “in the range of five to ten minutes” to deliver their oral arguments. “Does this mean that some interveners will get 10 minutes – or seven or eight minutes even – while others get five [minutes] or less?” Marinos asks. “How will this work with the court’s statement that intervener submissions, whether in writing, in person or orally, will be given equal consideration?”
The fight to return to in-person arguments
Since 2022, the SCC has required intervenors to appear before the court over Zoom. The policy dates back to the pandemic, but unlike appellants and respondents, who began presenting their arguments in person again after the pandemic, intervenors have had to continue appearing before the SCC remotely.
Several legal organizations have pushed back against this policy. In 2024, the CLA and the Women’s Legal Education and Action Fund submitted a joint letter to SCC Chief Justice Richard Wagner asking to overturn the policy; the next year, the CLA urged Wagner to consider the issue again.
Late last year, the SCC rejected requests by intervenor attorneys general and legal organizations to make their arguments in person in English Montreal School Board, et al. v. Attorney General of Quebec, et al., a historic case involving a record 51 intervenors.
The pilot project’s reintroduction of an in-person option for intervenors is something to be celebrated, DiGiuseppe says, arguing there are several benefits to the change.
“It really feels for many of us that intervening remotely, there’s simply just a distance that’s difficult to capture in words that many of us think affects our ability to engage the court,” DiGiuseppe says. “For the vulnerable populations that advocacy organizations like the CLA represent, we think there’s a symbolic significance to being present in the courtroom, and it just demonstrates that these vulnerable groups have an important place in our nation’s highest court and in the determination of this matter that's going to affect their interests.”
She adds that participating in SCC hearings represents an important professional moment for both experienced counsel and junior lawyers.
Sivalingam agrees.
“Obviously, the court [is] going to treat everything as equally as they can,” she says. “But there is an impact [when you’re appearing] in person and looking someone in the eye, reading the body language of judges and other people in the room.
“Whether the courts want to recognize it or not, there is an impact on, and a difference in advocacy in person and advocacy online,” she adds.