‘Middle step’ needed between non-co-operation and LSUC prosecution: Trudell

When it comes to dealing with lawyers who do not cooperate with Law Society of Upper Canada investigations, the regulator should consider another step before launching a formal prosecution, according to a Toronto defence lawyer.

Bill Trudell, who often represents lawyers before law society discipline hearing panels, says duty counsel should first intervene and reach out to the lawyer who is the subject of investigation.

“There needs to be a middle step, I think there should be an intervening step,” he says.

Trudell suggests creating a group of lawyers who offer to contact the person who is not responding to see whether they can help.

“It think it would save a lot of prosecutions, probably save money, and certainly saves people from getting into a situation like this,” he says.

Many lawyers, Trudell adds, don’t fully appreciate the damage they’re doing —including the possibility of getting a permanent discipline record — by not cooperating with law society investigations. They may not respond because they’re terrified, he says.

“You have to understand that as a self-regulator, one of the things we give up is the right to remain silent. We must respond, and I don’t think lawyers understand that,” he adds.

Trudell recently represented lawyer Matthew Igbinosun, who was suspended for a one month for not cooperating with a law society investigation. Trudell argued that Igbinosun should be reprimanded, but the hearing panel felt differently.

“A significant part of my finding — and Mr. Trudell has said how Mr. Igbinosun engaged — is, yes, he engaged, but the finding is he did not co-operate,” said hearing panel chair Susan Elliott.

The panel sought to send a strong message to the bar that not cooperating with a law society investigation is unacceptable, Trudell says, adding it’s a message that has yet to sink in with some lawyers.

Recent articles & video

Proposed competition law change could toughen merger review process: Stikeman Elliott's Peter Flynn

Roundup of law firm hires, promotions, departures: June 17, 2024 update

Federal Court of Appeal sets hearings for transportation, environmental law cases

'We need to have the competence to question:' LegalTech panel on genAI fakes in the legal system

MPD Law Firm LLP appears in $20-million commercial case

BC court orders new hearing on worker’s mental disorder claim due to expert's incomplete information

Most Read Articles

BC Supreme Court rejects husband’s claim against wife’s counsel over family home sale proceeds

Lawyer salaries may vary more in wake of competition law changes: recruiter report

Crown attorneys share responsibility for Canada’s dysfunctional justice system

Jennifer Teskey, the Canadian managing partner at Norton Rose Fulbright, on talent and motivation