SCC denies leave to Merchant Law Group LLP

The Supreme Court of Canada has denied leave to Merchant Law Group LLP to appeal a decision concerning a fraud action the government brought against the firm.

SCC denies leave to Merchant Law Group LLP
REUTERS/Chris Wattie

The Supreme Court of Canada has denied leave to Merchant Law Group LLP to appeal a decision concerning a fraud action the government brought against the firm.

The Supreme Court dismissed the Saskatchewan-based firm’s request for leave Thursday in the latest instalment in a long legal battle over $25 million the government was ordered to pay Merchant Law Group in 2008.

The federal government launched the civil action against Merchant Law Group in 2015 to try to reclaim the sum, which was paid to the firm for work it had done on behalf of Indian residential schools survivors. The government brought its claim after a review conducted by accounting firm Deloitte indicated Merchant Law Group had illegitimate time entries and excessive disbursements in its billing records.

The federal government claimed damages for fraud, deceit and fraudulent misrepresentation. The lawsuit alleged the firm falsely and intentionally represented it had incurred more unbilled time than it did, modified illegitimate time entries and submitted false claims for legal fees and disbursements it was not entitled to. These allegations have not been proven in court.

Merchant Law Group moved to have the government’s statement of claim struck, and a judge of the Court of Queen’s Bench granted the motion in 2016, finding the action was frivolous and vexatious. The Court of Appeal for Saskatchewan, however, allowed a government appeal and set aside the judge’s order to strike the claim.

In that decision, the Court of Appeal found that the action raises serious allegations of fraud that could not be properly addressed in previous proceedings and that require a full hearing.

Lawyer Holli Kuski Bassett, who represented Merchant Law Group in its leave application, says the positions being advanced by the government were previously rejected by Saskatchewan courts in 2006, 2007 and 2008.

“However, in this particular matter, the Court of Appeal determined it was premature to strike the government’s claim, and the Supreme Court of Canada did not grant leave to appeal from this decision,” she says.

Merchant Law Group is also pursuing its own claim against the government for an additional payment of $15 million plus disbursements, to which the firm claims it is entitled in accordance with the Indian Residential Schools Settlement Agreement — a $2-billion agreement that came into effect in 2007.   

Moira Dillon, a lawyer with Supreme Law Group who acted as Merchant Law Group’s Ottawa agent in its leave application, says the Supreme Court does not provide reasons on such applications, but the outcome is no doubt a disappointment for the firm.

“Every successful litigant hopes for finality, and this matter was previously litigated and clearly decided in their favour by the appeal court in prior proceedings,” says Dillon.


Free newsletter

The Canadian Legal Newswire is a FREE weekly newsletter that keeps you up to date on news and analysis about the Canadian legal scene. A separate InHouse Edition is delivered every two weeks, providing targeted news and information of interest to in-house counsel.

Please complete the form below to receive the weekly Canadian Legal Newswire and/or the Canadian Inhouse Legal Newswire.

Recent articles & video

Top Intellectual Property and Labour and Employment Boutiques

TrustLaw, Nextlaw team up in pro-bono boost

Gowling WLG says Brexit is informing large firms’ HQ choices

Major law firms pledge U$5 million for industry diversity

Ashurst hails "game changer hire" for project finance team

Beverley McLachlin bio provides insights into remarkable life and career

Most Read Articles

California now has toughest law in U.S. for the collection of personal information

Supreme Court of Canada set to hear appeals in Winnipeg

Beverley McLachlin bio provides insights into remarkable life and career

Digital privacy evolves in class actions