Despite exaggerated evidence, assessment of damages for future care must be based on evidence: court

Future-care damages, despite being predictive, are still an objective assessment on evidence: court

Despite exaggerated evidence, assessment of damages for future care must be based on evidence: court
Award of future care damages must be reasonable and grounded on evidence

The Court of Appeal for British Columbia has ruled that an assessment of damages for future care must be based on evidence presented despite the plaintiff’s exaggerated or unreliable evidence.

In Pang v. Nowakowski, 2021 BCCA 478, Pang was injured in two separate motor vehicle accidents and was awarded non-pecuniary damages, loss of past and future earning capacity, cost of future care and special damages. Pang appealed the cost of future care award on the ground that the award was inordinately low, that it had no proper evidence at trial, or alternatively, that the judge failed to provide sufficient reasons.

The appellate court agreed.

While assessment of damages for future care has an element of prediction or prophecy, the appellate court ruled that such assessment should “reflect a reasonable expectation of what the injured person would require to put them in a position they would have been but for the incident.” It is still an objective assessment on the evidence and must be fair to both parties, said the court.

In this case, the appellate court noted the trial judge’s plight in assessing Pang’s “exaggerated and unreliable” evidence. But the judge was still required to explain the basis of the award, having decided that some items were medically justified and that the amount claimed by Pang “far exceeded” what was reasonable.

While a reassessment of damages is occasionally done, the appellate court ruled that it is not possible in this case since the evidence central to the cost of future care award was seen and heard by the trial judge. As such, the appellate court remitted the cost of future care award to the trial court for reassessment.

Recent articles & video

Survey report highlights challenges and solutions for family violence cases in Nova Scotia courts

Suncor's David Kramer speaks about big deals, the energy transition and career advice

Lawyers must be increasingly aware of technological, geopolitical trends: software founder Sean West

Who made it to the 2024 list of top pro bono law firms?

Tracy Davis appointed as Assistant Chief Justice of the Alberta Court of Justice

Charles Randall Smith re-appointed as chairperson of RCMP External Review Committee

Most Read Articles

BC Supreme Court rejects husband’s claim against wife’s counsel over family home sale proceeds

Crown attorneys share responsibility for Canada’s dysfunctional justice system

Lawyer salaries may vary more in wake of competition law changes: recruiter report

'We need to have the competence to question:' LegalTech panel on genAI fakes in the legal system