Alberta Court of Appeal overturns approval of oil sands project, siding with First Nation

According to the court, true reconciliation requires genuine respect of Indigenous treaty rights

Alberta Court of Appeal overturns approval of oil sands project, siding with First Nation

In a unanimous decision, the Alberta Court of Appeal has overturned the Alberta energy Regulator’s approval of the proposed Prosper Petroleum Rigel oil sands project.

The Fort McKay First Nation dubbed the decision to rescind the approval both “historic” and “momentous.”

“From the start, Fort McKay wanted only fair consideration of our 20-year struggle to protect Moose Lake as the last intact piece of wilderness in our traditional territory, even as it was encroached upon by oil sands development,” said the First Nation.

According to Fort McKay, the decision has important implications for the meaning of reconciliation. True reconciliation requires genuine respect and consideration of Indigenous treaty rights and the co-creation of partnerships with Indigenous communities, they said.

The First Nation further stated that the decision recognizes that Moose Lake is sacred, provides the clarity needed to support Fort McKay’s economic recovery and orders that future proceedings reconsider the project. They expect the provincial government to approve the Moose Lake Plan in the late spring and to make a commitment to jointly protect the lake.

In the meantime, Fort McKay is continuing its work “to manage the impact of the global collapse of oil prices on our businesses and ensure the health and safety of our community members through the COVID-19 pandemic response.”

Recent articles & video

SCC orders Ontario and Canada to negotiate with First Nation on unpaid Treaty annuities

Credit curtailment, consolidation among impacts of SCC’s Redwater decision for oil and gas: lawyers

Canadian consumer insolvencies at highest in almost five years

The BoC is cutting, but has its pivot come too late?

Proactive approach needed for ‘huge change’ coming to GAAR tax law: Dentons

Ontario Superior Court grants father parenting schedule despite abuse and substance use allegations

Most Read Articles

BC Supreme Court grants limited spousal support due to economic hardship in 21-year marriage

Alberta court allows arbitration award to be entered as judgment in matrimonial dispute

State can be liable for damages for passing unconstitutional laws that infringe Charter rights: SCC

Lawyer suing legal regulator for discrimination claims expert witness violated practice standards